He's very cute! But in my opinion the background could be better.. I've never heard anything about this James Maslow , but as I can see from pictures on Google, he's a pretty handsome guy, your sim is pretty too, but personally I would have chosen a paler skin, (there are some awesome ones on Modthesims) in that way his pink cheeks (the original one seems to have them, not sure though..) and other details would be more visible
Cute sim but similarity with real James is not big. Anyway, sim looks nice. VISION - 5/10 ORIGINALITY - 6/10 - He looks nice and he has not ordinarily facial. TECHNIQUE - 6/10 ART IMPACT - 3/10 - Sim looks nice but you have minuses for: preview of only half hands of your sim, background is not too much beautiful - try take snapshot with your sim in nature or nicely decorated living room, snapshot can be better adjusted. COMPLETE RATING - 5
Unfortunately because you have two categories in yellow and one in red this creation can not stay in longer than 24 h. I wish to you better luck next time.